It’s Not OK

Dame Anne Salmond

The three Briefing Papers posted today were written by Professor Anne Salmond of the University of Auckland in response to what she describes as the Slippery Slope of Democracy in New Zealand. The first paper was written in the wake of Dirty Politics, the book released by Nicky Hager that has dominated the 2014 election campaign. The second paper was written in July 2013 and the third dates back to October 2011. What these papers address is a deeply held concern with the state of democratic government in New Zealand and a noticeable decline over the past several years in the integrity of government. 



August 2014

The Dirty Politics saga cuts to the heart of political life in New Zealand. Over the past ten years, there has been an insidious shift in the way that Government works, with increasingly autocratic, arrogant ministers taking away the levers of power from citizens and civil servants.

The independence of the civil service has been eroded, with Ministers routinely interfering in operational decisions. Last year, the Law Society felt impelled to report to the United Nations that Parliament had been used to pass a succession of Acts that strip away rights, freedoms and protections from ordinary citizens, in breach of the Bill of Rights. Ministerial accountability has become a farce.

It is this steady erosion of democratic checks and balances in New Zealand that makes politicians feel above the law, and contemptuous of those they represent. As the old adage goes, ‘Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.’ If many Kiwis feel disgusted with politics and politicians, and powerless at present, they have good reason.

If the Prime Minister’s office has indeed worked with the SIS to attack the Leader of the Opposition, or colluded with a muck-raking blogger to vilify people who disagree with the ruling party, this is reprehensible, and a constitutional disgrace. It is the kind of governance that makes Kiwis feel terrible about their own country. It’s not OK.

Unless executive power can be reined in, however, we can expect a succession and perhaps an acceleration of such abuses, no matter who is in power.

What’s needed is a truly independent and high level inquiry (perhaps a Royal Commission) to investigate the internal workings of government in New Zealand, and recommend a form of governance that has integrity, is truly democratic, and fit for the twenty-first century.

An election is one time when politicians are forced to listen to ordinary people. Kiwis from across the political spectrum have the chance to demand a much higher standard of conduct and decision-making from their elected representatives.

We have the right to live in a democracy where our leaders do not lie to us, or abuse their powers, or strip away our freedoms. They need to represent what’s best, not what’s worst about New Zealand. We are entitled to feel proud and confident about the way we’re governed, not embarrassed and ashamed.

There are decent people in all political parties. They must take urgent steps to clean up politics in New Zealand, and to restore democratic checks and balances to the political process. This is becoming so disreputable that it must adversely affect the everyday lives of politicians, and make them wonder what happened to their own ideals, and how they became complicit in such a dirty game.

Categories: Democracy
Dame Anne Salmond
About the author

Dame Anne Salmond

Professor - University of Auckland
Anne Salmond is a Distinguished Professor in Maori Studies and Anthropology at the University of Auckland, and the author of many award-winning books and articles on Maori life and early contacts between Europeans and islanders in Polynesia. She has has been honoured with a Prime Minister’s Award for Literary Achievement. She is a Foreign Associate of the National Academy of Sciences in the US and Corresponding Fellow of the British Academy, the only New Zealander to have won both awards. She is also a Fellow of the Royal Society of New Zealand; Fellow of the NZ Academy of the Humanities; and a Dame Commander of the British Empire. Anne Salmond is the Project Sponsor of the Starpath project, aimed at enhancing educational excellence for Maori, Pacific and low income students; patron of many community organisations; and an engaged environmentalist. In 2013 she became the Kiwibank New Zealander of the Year, and was awarded the Rutherford Medal, the Royal Society of New Zealand’s top scientific prize.